Mordor at Fangorn
Topic: Denethor was the most influential Steward of Gondor
Link: Mordor vs Fangorn
Winner: Fangorn

Rohan at Minas Tirith
Topic: Geography shaped the outcome of event in Middle-earth.
Link: Rohan vs MT
Winner: Minas Tirith

The Shire at Lothlorien
Topic: Elrond had more power and influence in Middle-earth than Galadriel.
Link: Shire vs Lorien
Winner: The Shire

Isengard at Khazad-dum
Topic: Sauron should not have given any Rings of Power to the Dwarves.
Link: Isengard vs KD
Winner: Khazad-dum

Round Two

Minas Tirith at the Shire
Topic: Saruman erred when he took Grima Wormtongue as his servant.
Link: MT vs Shire
Winner: Minas Tirth

Khazad-dum at Mordor
Topic: Dwarves in the Third Age were as important in the defeat of evil as Elves were.
Link: KD vs Mordor
Winner: Mordor

Fangorn at Isengard
Topic: The Battle of the Five Armies was more important than the second battle of Dale.
Link: Fangorn vs Isengard
Winner: Fangorn

Rivendell at Rohan
Topic: The Fellowship should not have stayed so long at Rivendell and Lothlorien.
Link: Rivvy vs Rohan
Winner: Rohan